Some Jamaicans have spoken out in favor of efforts to boycott Jamaican goods or music until leaders take serious action to reduce antigay vigilantism.
Perhaps most prominent among music-boycott supporters in 2008 was Gareth Henry, who was the co-chair of Jamaica Forum for Lesbians, Allsexuals, and Gays until he was forced to flee the country for Canada last year. J-FLAG publicly expressed disagreement with the 2008 music boycott, but according to Xtra.ca, Henry said that JFLAG could not be seen to publicly support a boycott.
“They can’t be the ones to call for the boycott,” he says. “They can’t be that voice. But the gays, lesbians and queers on the ground are supportive of a boycott.”
Henry says he’s tried talking to the government.
“We have tried numerous approaches, numerous dialogues with government officials,” he says. “They have been non-responsive to the call. We have to hit people where it’s going to hurt, where they’ll feel it. In the Jamaican context talk is cheap. After 10 years of JFLAG’s existence what else can we do?”
[Addendum: Henry opposes the 2009 boycott of goods and tourism that is advocated by BoycottJamaica.org.]
Stop Murder Music Canada (SMMC) advocated a boycott last year of Jamaican musicians whose songs contain violently homophobic lyrics .
Xtra.ca reported that Canada’s reggae community was split on the issue.
Christian Lacoste, an openly gay Montreal reggae fan who runs the website Murder Inna Dancehall, supported both the music boycott and an official immigration ban on visits by homophobic dancehall artists. But Cezar Brumeanu, who runs the Montreal International Reggae Festival and that city’s House of Reggae nightclub, opposed a boycott.
This year, Jamaican blogger Dave, supports BoycottJamaica.org, a newer boycott of Jamaican goods and tourism. Dave — who is forced to remain anonymous to protect his safety — says:
This could potentially devastate my country during this global recession but this is basically the only thing I can do to improve my living conditions without putting myself in physical danger. Jamaica sucks when it comes to addressing LGBT issues and I am tired of living under these stupid conditions. Obviously, LGBT issues require much more attention Worldwide, even in the US, but Jamaica just refuses to even give us any basic rights. And they NEVER speak out against violence against gays. I don’t F-ing care how long it takes, just Boycott our asses and pass the word along.
The goals of BoycottJamaica.org are modest: There is no requirement that Jamaica affirm same-sex orientation or legalize same-sex intimacy. Instead, BoycottJamaica calls for Jamaican officials to publicly commit to ending antigay violence, and for the Prime Minister to clearly and unequivocally condemn antigay violence and express regret for past violence.
But they refuse. Until Jamaican leaders declare a halt to antigay vigilantism, boycotts appear to be the only way for North American LGBT people and their allies to tell Jamaica that they will no longer subsidize Jamaicans’ war against their gay neighbors and against basic human decency in exported music.
Hat tip: Box Turtle Bulletin










How was Wayne Besen, the Founding Executive Director of Truth Wins Out, impacted by the situation in Jamaica?
Homophobia is Jamaica is as much about class as it is about sexuality. By affecting the livelihoods of any gay person in Jamaica we are making them more susceptible to dangerous homophobia.
Of course, the people behind this campaign know nothing about the actual situation and they have failed to consult the people affect by the issue.
This boycott presents a dangerous colonialist attitude that gay and straight Jamaican alike will reject.
There are people who have been working on this issue for decades and they know what is feasible, JFLAG, Stop Hate Music and people like Staceyann Chin, who was actually a victim of this violence.
I urge Wayne Besen to ready Staceyann’ Chin’ book (The Other Side of Paradise) and my statements and op-ed on the subject. And, I urge him to reconsider this campaign.
Zaheer Mustafa,
Do you oppose any form of boycott, or do you support a boycott of specific products and industries?
The status quo of government and commercial support for antigay violence is unacceptable. And it is unfortunate that boycott opponents, thus far, expect Americans to continue to spend their dwindling recreational dollars to subsidize antigay Jamaicans.
It is colonialist for Americans to subsidize Jamaican homophobia.
[...] blog has joined the debate in two posts. The first is a repost of Michael Airhart’s article on Jamaican voices in support of the boycott. The second is a post which defends JFLAG’s [...]
I oppose to people who know nothing about the Caribbean using flawed logic to put forth a boycott when they are unaware of who it will affect and how it will affect them. I also, oppose to well white gay men dictating how gay people of color needs to solve their problems. And finally, I oppose to natural born Americans stepping in to solve the problems of any Caribbean country.
Zaheer Mustafa, in other words, you support complete inaction to stop antigay violence.
Michael:
I am angry about and affected by this issue. Additionally, I have been a long time activist on this and other LGBT issues. I know what works and what doesn’t in the processing of changing systems of oppression.
This idea of a boycott was discussed about two years ago in the offices of GMAD in Harlem, NY. People who escaped from Jamaica were there, Caribbean activist were there. American allies were there. The meeting was long and in-depth and this idea was rejected.
Inaction is not an option but this group is dealing with an issue that they are completely unaware of and it will not create change. “We can no longer subsidize our own slaughter” is the line Wayne used in the press release. That is an insult Jamaicans who experience the slaughter and live in fear of it everyday. You are taking ineffective action and creating animosity at the same time. Ineffective and harmful action is also not an option.
At the end of the day, Jamaicans will not change their attitudes towards gay people because you are boycotting, the government will not change public policy and companies will not adjust their attitudes to compensate for their bottom-line. Why? because at the end of the day your group would not have done anything to change the heart and minds of Jamaicans.
I am not type of person that only seeks to breakdown ideas; I like to put forth ideas also. So here is one. Why not boycott American companies that do business in Jamaica? Every bit of research I have read on changing systems of oppression indicates that you might actually be able to create change by going that route. At the end of the day, American companies care more about their image than any Jamaica company every will.
Mustafa:
Gay people should be able to live openly and honestly on every square inch of God’s green earth. We will oppose, without hesitation, any nation or group that disagrees with this premise.
We are all citizens of the world, and I will not sit back and watch gay people be beaten and killed. A country’s sovereignty does not give it a right to abuse GLBT people. Period. A gay person’s dignity transcends a country’s borders.
This is Propaganda at its best how do you get the title of this post to be Gay Jamaicans Voice Support for Boycotts ? when there is obviously a very balance view on the topic. The Gay Jamaicans who support the boycott are those that are seeking asylum in the US. The rest understand that a boycott will never work we are decedents of slaves and maroons we fought plantation owners for our freedom and we not let anyone hold anything over us we remain steadfast and relentless no matter what.
Reselent Jamaican- why bother. I’m sure this person has no idea what you are talking about when you invoke the legacy of maroons. These avid boycotters know nothing about Jamaica other than what their sheltered, privileged tourism has taught them.
As it happens, I studied both Caribbean history and anthropology in college. I know what maroons are. My minor course of study was in Latin American Studies and economic development.
As for balance, the opposition of some gay Jamaicans to boycotts is already well-known. I was merely drawing attention to the fact that some Jamaicans support the boycotts, as softer measures have not lessened the violence.
North Americans don’t like it when their tourist dollars are used to injure and kill people. To stop the boycotts, simply take steps to stop the violence.
Zaheer Mustafa wrote: because at the end of the day your group would not have done anything to change the heart and minds of Jamaicans.
So if that’s the case, why should it matter if we should continue this boycott and not spend our tourist dollars in Jamaica? The more people that know about it, friends and families of gay people, the less it will be likely that they will travel to Jamaica as well or purchase Jamaican products.
Still, in your eyes it won’t have done a thing.
To us it will be a step in making this world a safer place for all LGBT people.
I am still patiently waiting for boycott opponents to recommend constructive alternative methods of stopping the violence. (Did I just hear a pin drop?)
I am reposting the because it seems that people are missing the point.
1. there is an alternative. American boycott companies that do business with Jamaica.
2. the is and has been action taken.
Those were my previous points, detailed below. Here are my new points. Just ignore this group and let then go away. They are clearly unorganized and know nothing about the country. They even choose products that are not really Jamaican as symbols for the boycott. You three are really just a bunch of over privileged men trying to make a name for your self. Funders will ignore you after they see the major mistakes you made in this process and trust me they will hear about it. A group that refuses to listen to the people they seek to empower will surely fold.
I am angry about and affected by this issue. Additionally, I have been a long time activist on this and other LGBT issues. I know what works and what doesn’t in the processing of changing systems of oppression.
This idea of a boycott was discussed about two years ago in the offices of GMAD in Harlem, NY. People who escaped from Jamaica were there, Caribbean activist were there. American allies were there. The meeting was long and in-depth and this idea was rejected.
Inaction is not an option but this group is dealing with an issue that they are completely unaware of and it will not create change. “We can no longer subsidize our own slaughter” is the line Wayne used in the press release. That is an insult Jamaicans who experience the slaughter and live in fear of it everyday. You are taking ineffective action and creating animosity at the same time. Ineffective and harmful action is also not an option.
At the end of the day, Jamaicans will not change their attitudes towards gay people because you are boycotting, the government will not change public policy and companies will not adjust their attitudes to compensate for their bottom-line. Why? because at the end of the day your group would not have done anything to change the heart and minds of Jamaicans.
I am not type of person that only seeks to breakdown ideas; I like to put forth ideas also. So here is one. Why not boycott American companies that do business in Jamaica? Every bit of research I have read on changing systems of oppression indicates that you might actually be able to create change by going that route. At the end of the day, American companies care more about their image than any Jamaica company every will.
Thank you for the suggestion to boycott American companies doing business in Jamaica, Zaheer. It is an excellent idea.
Zaheer Mustafa, you say you know what works and what doesn’t, but the violence in Jamaica has only gotten worse. From that it is clear you do not know what works. Its time to try something different, and a boycott is it.
Worldfocus.org: There are no gay pride parades in Jamaica
Every June, gay pride is celebrated across the U.S. Lisa Biagiotti, who recently returned from reporting on HIV/AIDS and homophobia in Jamaica, answers questions about why such gay pride parades do not exist in Jamaica.
There are no gay pride parades in Jamaica
http://worldfocus.org/blog/2009/06/29/there-are-no-gay-pride-parades-in-jamaica/6047