John Shore has a couple of essential posts up on the subject of Christianity and its fundamentalist contingent’s connection to the bullying and suicide of gay teens. They are both required reading, but let’s start with his explanation, as a Christian who affirms the dignity of LGBT people, of that connection:
In the conversations centered around such tragedies as the recent Jamey Rodemeyer suicide, we very often find conservative Christians defending themselves against the accusation that the theology in which they believe–and specifically their belief that homosexuality is a sin against God—ultimately contributes to that which informs, motivates, and encourages the bullying of gay teens. I thought I would make this video as a way of illustrating for such Christians how the reasoning by which they absolve themselves of all responsibility for gay teen suicides and the bullying of gay teens tends to sound to those who do not share their religious convictions.
Here’s the video. Stop and watch it, please.
In the post just prior to that video, he speaks directly to fundamentalists who love their dogma more than they love people:
If you’re a Christian who believes that being gay is a morally reprehensible offense against God, then you share a mindset, worldview, and moral structure with the kids who hounded Jamey Rodemeyer, literally, to death. It is your ethos, your convictions, and your theology that informed, supported, and encouraged their cruelty.
We Christians who believe that God created gay people as much in His own image as he did straight people are begging you to reconsider your theology — to do nothing more than be open to an alternative, fully credible, scholastically sound interpretation of one or two lines from Paul.
How can you be unwilling to do something so simple, when you see the horrible ultimate cost of that refusal?
Christ died so that you could love more. And now you’re part of a system that allows that same Christ to be used as a moral justification for the most vile kind of abuse. How could that have happened? How could something so right have gone so wrong?
Turn, friend.
People who affirm LGBT people have the moral high ground, whether atheist, Christian, Jewish or whatever else. This is not bragging — it’s a simple fact. It’s particularly powerful and refreshing, though, to hear a Christian speak so firmly to those of his own religion who inflict so much harm [whether they realize or admit it], for the sake of a couple of Bible verses they love to misunderstand. Keep on, John Shore.










Queen Mary of England (Roman Catholic):
“As the souls of heretics are to be forever burning in hell, there can be nothing more proper than for me to imitate the Divine vengeance by burning them on earth.”
Religious reformer Philip Melanchthon (Protestant):
“Why should we treat them [i.e. heretics] any better in this life than God is going to treat them in the next?”
Rationale for anti-gay bullying:
“Since evangelical, fundamentalist, Bible-believing religious leaders assure us that homosexuals are going to go to hell to suffer for all eternity, why should we treat them any better in this life than God is going to treat them in the next?”
Turn, friend.
Fat chance. More power to him, I completely respect his right to try and get some of them to open their eyes to what they’re doing, but fat chance. The theology isn’t motive, it’s cover. The abuse isn’t a bug, it’s a feature.
William– I really like that. can I steal it?
Imitation is the sincerest form of plagiarism.
William, please say yes. I want to steal it too.
Ben in Oakland & Karen:
Yes, by all means steal it if you want. The statements of Queen Mary and Melanchthon must be well out of copyright by now anyway.
This is what makes the haters so dangerous–they feel that they are just initiating God’s vengence on GLBT people, so the sky is basically the limit where GLBT people are concerned. This is why they feel entitled to bully, taunt, beat us within an inch of our lives, or just flat-out murder us.
But YOU are not out of copyright,
I don’t think that one can claim any copyright on remarks written on an Internet blog. I think it’s a bit like a letter, which, once sent – in UK law anyway – becomes the property of the recipient, not the sender. LOL.
Thanks for this, Evan. Step by step, and all that.
Has anyone noticed how Christians react when challenged on their homophobic hating?
‘Well, I follow the Bible and the Bible says it’s wrong’.
‘It’s not me, it’s God who says it’s a sin’
Well, what about other things in the Bible?
What about loving others?
And visiting the sick and prisoners and the old?
And responding to hate with gentleness and forgiveness?
And doing good deeds without showing off about it because your Father in Heaven sees it and His reward is enough?
And going the extra mile to help your enemies?
And being kind and charitable to those who least deserve it?
No, they push all these Biblical commands off the table, so they can make more room for;
HOMOSEX IS A SIN AND GOD WILL PUNISH YOU.
I swear by all that’s reasonable, these people(?) are more obsessed with homosexuals and what they do than LGBT people are themselves.
Wow, that Queen Mary was one sick, twisted b***h.