Some things never change. One of the unshakable axioms of the Catholic church is that bishops who toe the line get promoted. This morning, the Vatican presented American Catholics with exhibit A when it announced that New York archbishop and United States Conference of Catholic Bishops president Timothy Dolan will be elevated to the rank of cardinal by Pope Benedict XVI next month.
Considering that the New York archdiocese is widely regarded as the spiritual heart of the Catholic church in America and that eight out of New York’s ten archbishops have been named cardinals, it was only a matter of time before Dolan got the red hat. Still, given the great deal of respect Dolan’s peers have for the archbishop, the visibility of his current office, and the fact that his charm and media savvy have made him the de facto face of the American Catholic church, many people were surprised that it took Rome this long to move on his promotion.
I find it particularly telling that Benedict only created Dolan a cardinal after he made the fight against marriage equality a top priority of both his episcopate and the USCCB. In New York, Dolan spearheaded the opposition to the state’s marriage equality law. While the bill was being debated, Archbishop Dolan frantically worked to torpedo it, saying that allowing loving and committed same-sex couples the freedom to marry would turn the State of New York into a communist dictatorship. He called marriage equality “perilous,” “detrimental for the common good,” and a “violation of what we consider natural law that’s embedded in every man and woman.” He railed against same-sex marriage in a series of blog posts, characterizing it as “Orwellian social engineering.” In the same post, he compared marriage equality to polygamy, and went further in an interview on 60 Minutes in March, saying “I love my mom. I don’t have the right to marry her.”
Dolan’s anti-gay rhetoric didn’t stop after the law passed. He whined that he had been tricked by the politicians who cast their votes for fairness and lied that Catholic churches in his diocese were being threatened with lawsuits intended to force them to perform same-sex weddings, despite the fact that the law explicitly prohibited such suits. And he doubled down on his rhetoric about the “threat” to marriage posed by loving same-sex couples, comparing their marriages to “polygamy, adultery, and forced marriages.”
The United States Conference of Catholic Bishops has taken a similarly aggressive tack under Dolan’s leadership, forming a so-called subcommittee “for the Promotion and Defense of Marriage” dedicated to opposing equal marriage rights. This group is so extreme that its Policy Advisor for Marriage and Family, Daniel Avila, was forced to resign late last year after publishing an inflammatory column in which he stated that homosexuality is caused by Satan.
Apparently, engaging in consistent spiritual abuse of LGBT people so endeared him to Catholic leaders in Rome that they gave him a promotion. The worst part? All cardinals under the age of 80 are eligible to vote in a papal conclave (election). Benedict XVI is in failing health, and Dolan’s young age (at 61, he’s a veritable spring chicken among his fellow cardinals, whose average age in 2010 was 78) ensures that he’ll be able to help vote another anti-gay pope into office after the current one dies, and is likely to be able to repeat the feat at least once more. And the cycle of institutional homophobia in the Catholic church continues.










Although this post give a strong summary of the Catholic Church’s recent political gay bashing, it nonetheless falls into the trap of using the kind of language that ultimate boosts the Church’s ability to continue getting away with its crimes. To say that New York is the “spiritual heart of the Catholic Church in America” is the kind of the thing the Church wants you saying, but which you should not be saying. Why should an organization that excommunicates one for ordaining a woman but not for raping children be described as having a “spiritual heart” anywhere?
An astute point.
For me, though, “heart” is different from “soul.” For example, the Mormon Church — another persecutor of LGBTs — is headquartered in Salt Lake City, and I would have no qualms about referring to that city as the “spiritual heart” of that church.
Whether or not either of those organizations have a soul is another matter entirely.
It’s ashamed that people like this lead my Church.
“I love my mom. I don’t have the right to marry her.” – Of course not, she’s your family. I’m pretty sure the gay people that are in loving, committed relationships right now aren’t in that relationship with their family members. How is gay marriage equivalent to polygamy? It isn’t, marriage is a union between two people. And adultery? forced marriages? I could go on and on. It’s a shame that a small number of Catholics make the majority of us seem intolerant as well.
@AF96, this is known as “attacking a straw man”. When your opponent’s true position is unassailable, you restate their position as something that’s easier to attack and attack that instead. Marriage equality is difficult to argue against, but arguing against adultery and forced marriage is much easier.
And yes, it is a tactic employed by people who are desperate and afraid they are going to lose the debate.
s**t floats.
Again, if marriage between 1 man and 1 woman and having mucho children is ‘God’s Law’; why do RC clergy have to remain single and celibate (at least on paper). In real life we know that a significant portion of them are neither celibate nor heterosexual.
Also, this is kind of a pyrrhic victory for the ultra conservative hierarchy. Their bigoted and long out-dated policies will just continue to alienate and drive out the younger generations. They must be hurting because they are now actually advertising on television (in the Philadelphia/New York area anyway) for people to return to the Catholic Church. So sandwiched in between commercials for Geico and the latest deal at Taco Bell, you can see lots of happy, peppy people taking part in RC church activities and sacraments (all being performed most likely by a Gay priest).
[...] Source: http://www.truthwinsout.org/blog/2012/01/21303/ [...]
[...] York Archbishop Timothy Dolan, recently elevated to the rank of cardinal, made the (ultimately unsuccessful) fight against marriage equality in New [...]
[...] York Archbishop Timothy Dolan, recently elevated to the rank of cardinal, made the (ultimately unsuccessful) fight against marriage equality in New [...]
[...] Catholic-centered strategy play out all across the country, from then-Archbishop Timothy Dolan taking the lead in opposing marriage equality in New York to Minneapolis-St. Paul Archbishop John Nienstedt [...]
[...] Catholic-centered strategy play out all across the country, from then-Archbishop Timothy Dolan taking the lead in opposing marriage equality in New York to Minneapolis-St. Paul Archbishop John Nienstedt [...]
[...] U.S. Catholic Church’s Chief Homophobe Gets Promotion (truthwinsout.org) Share this:FacebookEmailShareDiggPress ThisPrintRedditStumbleUpon [...]
[...] than perhaps any other prelate in the country (with possible competition from New York Cardinal Timothy Dolan), Nienstedt has made the fight against marriage equality into a top priority. He’s inserted a [...]
[...] to Weinstein, Ryan, et al: consider using the American Catholic bishops and Rick Santorum as test subjects for this future study. I have a sneaking [...]
[...] have refused.) Coincidence? I think not. In today’s Catholic hierarchy, it’s becoming increasingly clear: bash the gays, get [...]
[...] with opposite-gender parents. It will force the indoctrination of kindergarteners. It will lead to communist dictatorship and men marrying children and [...]
[...] couples like my husband and me. Slick, media-savvy personalities like New York’s Cardinal Timothy Dolan can talk about how much they love LGBT people until they’re blue in the face, and church [...]
[...] we’ve documented extensively here at TWO, the American Catholic bishops have made the preservation of marriage discrimination and the spiritual bullying of LGBT people [...]